–Whitlam had it easier on China policy

February 20, 2018

The Coalition government has resisted US pressure to undertake freedom of navigation operations in response to Chinese territorial expansion in the South China Sea.

The Coalition government has resisted US pressure to undertake freedom of navigation operations in response to Chinese territorial expansion in the South China Sea.

Photo: US Navy

But the rapidity and scale of China’s rise has traumatised some in Australia’s defence and security establishment. It’s easy to imagine their anxiety last year, for example, when they read the poll of the ASEAN Studies Centre in Singapore that showed that 74 per cent of opinion leaders in Southeast Asia see China as the most influential country in their future, only three percent the US.

Perhaps the worst part of the recent China panic was the demonisation of Chinese students as spies and bullies. One writer, with no evidence, said they were espousing “racial chauvinism”. There are 131,355 Chinese university students in Australia and a sober survey of the stories showed the evidentiary base for the raft of inflammatory headlines was a mere four incidents.

That is, a mere four incidents of Chinese students disagreeing with a lecturer. In no case did they close down discussion. No university told their lecturers to apologise. When students at the University of Newcastle told their teacher he was wrong to imply Taiwan was a separate country they were expressing Australia’s effective diplomatic position, not just China’s.

Last year media reported that ASIO had briefed political parties that two Shenzhen/Guangzhou property developers who had donated to political parties enjoy links to the Chinese Communist Party. Any prominent Chinese business figure is likely to have links of some kind with the ruling party in a country that, regrettably, remains a one party state.

One of the property developers – the one who, as it happens, donated to Tony Burke’s campaign – has been an Australian citizen for 20 years. To treat him as still Chinese, not Australian, is to apply a different standard to a Chinese migrant than would be applied to a migrant from Europe who founds a business and chooses to donate to political parties. That is a big departure from the principle of Australia’s multiculturalism that says our one test is citizenship not country of origin.


One Australian academic, Clive Hamilton, attacks university collaboration with Chinese entities. This is a sad example of some Australians becoming bewildered (even outraged) as an Asian power pulls ahead. Is Hamilton saying the Chinese might steal our advantage in high-speed rail? They have about 25,000 kilometres of it and we have none. Or that they would steal our supercomputing expertise? They’ve had the world’s fastest supercomputer since 2010. They lead us in artificial intelligence or quantum communications. The truth is we now have more to gain from research collaboration than they from us.

Within the last 10 years second-tier Chinese cities have grown to look like Singapore. The generation emerging from their universities is the biggest cohort of English-speaking graduates in the world. Southern China used to produce 70 per cent of the world’s shoes. It now produces 70 per cent of the world’s drones.

I would like to think that this was happening as China moved to democracy but a realist foreign policy stays loyal to our own values, deals with China as it is and stays open to change.

Whitlam put it with his typical eloquence: “We seek a relationship with China based on friendship, cooperation and mutual trust, comparable with that which we have, or seek, with other major powers.” Or we could even take John Howard’s advice that dealing with China is simple: you set aside the areas of difference and work on the things you have in common.

Bob Carr is Director of the Australia-China Relations Institute, University of Technology Sydney. He is a former premier of NSW and foreign minister.

Morning & Afternoon Newsletter

Delivered Mon–Fri. – #1 News in a FLASH

Twitter – @realnewsco

The NLP Directory – Get Help

Melbourne.GOLD Book a Tradie or a Pro

HDO – Hotel Directory Online

TRUMPn – Real News and Market

VOGUE Model Agency – News Magazine


Spoil a Princess – Princess Awards

NYC Planet Girls –

Check Us Out Magazine

Superstar news – Hollywood Gossip News

LUSH Wednesday Melbourne World Weather Check

Checkusin compare Hotels & Flights

GossBOSS Celebrity Hot Gossip News

Article Categories:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *